M’ville man arrested in murder case released due to ‘rock solid’ alibi

  • Friday, June 2, 2017 1:20pm
  • News

By Eric Stevick

For The Globe

EVERETT — A Marysville man booked for investigation of murder this week has been released from the Snohomish County Jail after detectives confirmed the story he gave when detained for questioning.

“He provided us a credible alibi,” sheriff’s spokeswoman Shari Ireton said Friday.

A woman who told detectives she watched the man fatally attack a south Everett woman remains in the jail. She’s being held for investigation of rendering criminal assistance. She has admitted driving the victim’s car, possessing her cell phone and using her credit cards, court papers say.

It wasn’t clear where the investigation is headed now. “We are looking at several persons of interest,” Ireton said.

Carl Bustard, 59, was released from jail Thursday night. He’d been held on $5 million bail after a judge found probable cause for his arrest.

Bustard is represented by Everett attorney Anna Goykhman. She said Friday that the defense connected detectives with witnesses who provided her client a “rock solid alibi.” It soon became clear that Bustard was the victim of a rush to judgment by police and what appears to be an attempt by a witness to frame him for the killing, Goykhman said.

“Police and prosecutors make mistakes which result in innocent people being charged and even convicted more often than they (or we as a society) would care to admit,” she said. “Sometimes it is decades before an innocent person is exonerated. I’m glad that, although my client’s life will never be the same after such a horrible experience, his name was cleared.”

The body of the victim, 50, was discovered in her home south of Everett Tuesday. She had suffered multiple stab wounds.

Detectives believe the woman was killed in her home in the 12000 block of 4th Avenue W in Everett. They initially believed she died May 25, based on what the other suspect — Tammie Lewis, 54 — told detectives. Bustard adamantly denied her allegations and told police she is mentally unstable and a liar.

The bail for Lewis remains at $250,000. The woman also goes by the last name Peterson.

Lewis told detectives she recently had been staying at the victim’s home.

Another roommate called 9-1-1 Tuesday to report that he had discovered the victim’s body in her bedroom after smelling a foul odor for a couple of days. He told detectives he hadn’t seen the victim for several days.

Release of the victim’s name is pending from the medical examiner’s office, as well as the cause and manner of death.

More in News

Hands Together homeless shelter reluctantly shuts doors

ARLINGTON – The Hands Together shelter is shutting its doors this year… Continue reading

Longtime Tulalip Tribes leader Stan Jones dies

TULALIP – Stan Jones, a longtime leader of the Tulalip Tribes, died… Continue reading

Election: Arlington mayor’s race still the closest

With the number of votes to count dwindling, the closest race locally… Continue reading

Arlington honors service members, military families during Veterans Day Parade

ARLINGTON – Flag-waving Arlington residents and visitors honored military service members past… Continue reading

Police: Arlington man not wearing seat belt dies in crash

ARLINGTON – A 50-year old Arlington man died when he lost control… Continue reading

Mental health court in Marysville a big success

MARYSVILLE – For eight years, Cecilio Smith was homeless and off and… Continue reading

Prosecutor: Arlington teen wanted bomb ‘mayhem’ not injuries

By Zachariah Bryan zbryan@heraldnet.com ARLINGTON — A teen who set off a… Continue reading

Mayor Nehring not a big fan of roundabouts either

MARYSVILLE – Mayor Jon Nehring admitted he is not a fan of… Continue reading

State to audit Marysville schools’ academics

MARYSVILLE – The Marysville School District has enough low-performing schools that the… Continue reading

MG student wins Community Service award

MARYSVILLE – Elise Sumsion of Marysville Getchell High School is the first… Continue reading

Elections update: Mayor leading by slim margin, city council to see change, voters backing fireworks ban

A mayor’s race too close to call, an incumbent city councilmember struggling… Continue reading

Mayor Barb Tolbert and challenger Don Vanney
More ballots counted, but local election results change little

An incumbent Marysville school board member and a former Marysville City Council… Continue reading