Brace yourselves for out-of-control spending
August 27, 2008 · Updated 8:35 PM
Make no mistake about it: the central economic problem facing the United States is out-of-control federal spending and the massive federal debt that continues to pile up. As welfare-state and warfare-state spending has continued to soar for the past seven years, U.S. officials have gone on a massive borrowing spree. Since 2000, the national debt has almost doubled from $5.67 trillion to $9 trillion.
It is out-of-control federal spending and the massive borrowing that has accompanied it that is at the core of the mortgage crisis. How could sucking all that money out of the capital markets to finance federal expenditures not have an effect on the availability of private capital in the home-loan market?
It is out-of-control federal spending and the Federal Reserve policy that is accommodating it that is at the core of the dollar crisis. How could the printing of money to pay off the debt not have an adverse effect on the value of the dollar?
Imagine the following scenario in your family. For the past 10 years, your familys annual income has been $80,000 while expenditures have totaled $100,000. To cover the excess, you have run up credit-card charges of $200,000. The solution is obvious: slash spending to the point that it is less than your income. In that way, a portion of your income is then freed up to pay the interest on your debt and also to pay down the principal.
The problem facing the hypothetical family is the problem facing the United States. Ever since 9/11, federal spending has gone through the roof, far exceeding the tax revenues of the government. Year after year, U.S. officials have borrowed the difference, without any heed to the long-term economic consequences.
One way to address the problem is to raise taxes to the point that tax revenues exceed government spending. The problem with that approach is that it continues to suck billions of dollars of income and savings out of the private, productive sector and transfer it to the government, non-productive sector.
The better solution is to slash expenditures so that spending is less than tax revenues, which would enable U.S. officials to begin paying down the principal on the debt. How likely is that? Not likely at all. Keep in mind, after all, that we are talking generally about two different types of expenditures those of the welfare state and those of the warfare state.
What are the chances that Americans will tolerate a major slashing of welfare-state programs? Answer: None. After all, does anyone honestly believe that Americans would accept massive reductions of such major welfare-state programs as Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, educational grants, and farm subsidies?
What about the warfare state? The problem is no different. There is no possibility that either President Bush or Congress would agree to the type of major slashing that would be required to rein in military spending. After all, would they agree to immediately withdraw all troops from Iraq in order to save all that money? Would they agree to close the Pentagons more than 700 overseas bases in more than 100 countries? Would they agree to drastically reduce the Pentagons budget for its global war on terrorism and its never-ending preparation for the next war? Not on your life. In the minds of the president and most members of Congress, that would mean surrendering to the terrorists and jeopardizing national security.
So whats the way out of this welfare-warfare economic vise? As a practical matter, there is no way out because neither welfare-state spending nor warfare-state spending is going to be slashed. We all know that. The debt will continue to mount. The Federal Reserve will continue to print the money to pay off the debt. The dollar will continue to plummet.
My advice? Given that the American people and their federal officials are not yet ready to give up on either their welfare state or the warfare state and the massive expenditures that are needed to fund them, my advice would be the same Id give people on a ship heading directly toward an iceberg: Brace yourselves.
Jacob Hornberger is president and founder of The Future of Freedom Foundation (www.fff.org).