WTH is with the RPI

What the heck is with the Ratings Percentage Index?

As the winner of the District 3A boys basketball title, it didn’t seem right that Marysville-Pilchuck High School’s boys basketball team didn’t get an automatic bid to state.

There are nine districts in the state. Each district winner should get an automatic bid to the Tacoma Dome.

Instead, the top eight seeds get to play in the dome. If they lose there, they still get a chance to come up through the loser’s bracket to place.

The other eight seeds, 9-16, must win play-in games to go to the dome. So, even though M-P won its district championship, it was rated 10th in the state’s RPI ranking system. So it had to play Mount Spokane and ended up losing.

The WIAA, in seeding teams, uses an RPI system that breaks down like this — 25 percent for a team’s winning percentage, 50 percent for its opponents’ winning percentage and 25 percent for its opponents’ opponents’ winning percentage. Still with me?

This percentage makes no sense. It can be more beneficial for a team to lose to a really good team than to beat a really bad one. A common criticism of RPI is that it puts too much weight on winning percentages of a team’s opponents, and not enough on its own wins.

A solution would be to give the team’s own winning percentage more weight – such as 40 percent or more.

Even without an automatic birth as district champion, M-P still would have gone straight to state, ranking eighth with that formula. They would have gotten in, and Rainier Beach would have had to win a play-in game. All the other teams would have been the same.

The WIAA needs to take another look at the playoff system. Each district champion should advance to make the those playoffs more meaningful. And a team’s overall winning percentage should play a larger role in deciding which other teams advance.

More in Sports

Anthony Whitis, in yellow, listens with his team to Eagle coach Greg Dailer at practice earlier this season. Whitis, a senior, led Arlington to a come-from-behind win over Ferndale Friday night.
Eagle QB leads Arlington to comeback win; M-P blanks foe

ARLINGTON – Eagle quarterback Anthony Whitis has been able to do something… Continue reading

M-P, MG swimmers win 4 events in meet against Cascade (slide show)

MARYSVILLE – The combined Marysville-Pilchuck and Marysville Getchell swim teams won four… Continue reading

Arlington edges MG in tennis (slide show)

Wrapup of Wednesday’s varsity prep scores

M-P boys beat Lakewood; Arlington volleyball undefeated (slide show)

MARYSVILLE – The Marysville-Pilchuck boys tennis team won its home match against… Continue reading

M-P, Arlington, Lakewood all win in football

MARYSVILLE – Bryan Sanders and Trenton Hurst each ran for more than… Continue reading

MG senior wins easily in home cross country meet

MARYSVILLE – Senior Evan Krautkremer won the boys race by 30 seconds… Continue reading

Arlington, M-P runners stand out at cross country meet (slide show)

MARYSVILLE – Both Arlington and Marysville-Pilchuck had some strong individual performances at… Continue reading

M-P swim team picks up a win, but MG falls

MARYSVILLE – Marysville-Pilchuck’s girls swim team beat Oak Harbor Tuesday at home… Continue reading

Most Read